“Holy shit” is an advance on the reader's attention: it says that something deserves surprise before the next sentence explains what actually happened.

I recently looked at several popular Chinese-language X posts that all began with the same exclamation, wocao, roughly “holy shit.” It is easy to wonder whether those two characters are a shortcut to reach.

The more useful question is what the post gives the reader after the exclamation.

1. The same opening can lead to very different reasons to read

The six posts I examined had roughly 90,000 to 470,000 views when I read them. Their openings looked similar; their appeal was different. The quotations below are English renderings of the Chinese openings.

“Holy shit! Holy shit! Holy shit! The full ‘list of self-destructive choices’ going viral on Weibo.” There is tension in the subject, a promise of completeness in “the full list,” and social proof in its popularity on another platform.

“Holy shit! ... From open source to closed source, and now leaving the scene altogether.” The sequence of changes is already a story. What happened, and why did it change again?

“Holy shit, this is good, Dan Koe ...” A familiar name adds authority. The discussion of AI, one-person businesses, and making money then gives a particular audience a reason to care.

“Holy shit!!! So this is how everyone builds a network!!!” The implication is that other people know something you might have missed. Building professional relationships also concerns a broad audience.

“Holy shit, I wish I had watched this Zhang Yiming video earlier ...” A familiar figure, regret at missing out, and the benefit promised later in the post reinforce each other.

“Holy shit, these 9 minutes from a Tsinghua psychology student ...” The university label suggests authority, 9 minutes makes the commitment feel small, and a later claim that the video was taken down adds scarcity.

I am analyzing the wording here, not verifying the identities, events, or promised benefits in those posts.

What Is Left of a Viral X Post Without “Holy Shit”? Six Examples and a Writing Method · Figure 1

Remove the exclamation and those appeals remain. Copying only the shout may miss what actually made people keep reading.

2. The emotion arrives before the fact

Usually, we encounter a fact and then decide how to react.

Starting with an exclamation reverses that sequence. Before explaining the event, the writer has already told us they are surprised.

That may create curiosity. It can also sound like a friend forwarding something with a casual “look at this.”

But emotional volume and tension in the subject are different things.

What Is Left of a Viral X Post Without “Holy Shit”? Six Examples and a Writing Method · Figure 2

Exclamation marks and exaggerated words can turn up the volume. Tension comes from a contrast in the facts, an unanswered question, or consequences that matter to the reader.

“Holy shit, this tool is incredible!” is loud. It still has not told us what the tool does well, who it helps, or what problem it solves.

Berger and Milkman's 2012 study explored emotion and sharing. They analyzed 6,956 articles that appeared on The New York Times homepage, primarily examining whether an article reached the most-emailed list over the previous 24 hours. High-arousal emotions such as awe, anger, and anxiety, along with surprise and practical usefulness, were positively associated with that outcome. Sadness had the opposite association.

The paper also used randomized experiments to examine the effects of particular emotions on self-reported willingness to share.

That research concerns emotion and sharing. It does not directly establish that opening a Chinese post with wocao produces more impressions on X. The platform, language, expression, and measured outcome are all different.

3. Finding popular examples does not establish cause and effect

X's publicly released recommendation implementation predicts a particular reader's engagement, time spent, and negative feedback, among other signals, then ranks content for that person.

That does not mean the system assigns a special bonus to this particular word. Nor does public code verify every experiment running in production.

A handful of popular posts certainly cannot establish this chain:

Exclamatory opening → more early engagement → distribution to a larger audience.

What Is Left of a Viral X Post Without “Holy Shit”? Six Examples and a Writing Method · Figure 3

Every step still needs evidence. Engagement might produce more distribution, but more exposure might also come first and produce more engagement.

An account's existing audience, the popularity of the topic, its images and video, and the network through which it spreads can all affect the outcome. Without a comparable version under the same conditions, it is hard to attribute the result to the opening word.

There is selection bias too. We see popular posts that use the exclamation. We do not necessarily see the posts that used exactly the same word and went nowhere.

These cases are useful for studying writing, not for proving a formula.

4. A practical method for writing your own X posts

Whatever kind of post you write, draft it with these five steps before deciding whether it needs an exclamation.

1. Write one sentence you will not publish

This post is for __. After reading it, that person will be able to __.

Make the second half specific. The reader might be able to check whether an opening conveys information, decide whether a tool fits their needs, or carry out a task.

The benefit need not be a tutorial. A new fact, a well-supported alternative view, or an experience worth reading can also give someone a reason to stay.

2. Gather the facts and examples before giving your verdict

List what you can actually provide: verified features, data with sources, your own experience, or specific examples that support your argument.

“This tool is incredible” is an opinion. If you have verified the features, “your files never need to be uploaded, and it works offline” gives the reader something concrete to evaluate. Do not turn a guess into a supposed test result just to make an opening more impressive.

What Is Left of a Viral X Post Without “Holy Shit”? Six Examples and a Writing Method · Figure 4

3. Try three openings for the same material

For this article, I could try:

  • A question: What is left of these popular X posts when you remove “holy shit”?
  • A contrast: These 6 popular posts start with the same exclamation, but give readers different reasons to continue.
  • A use: Before publishing an X post, try this deletion test to check whether the first sentence contains specific information.

The choice depends on whom you want to keep reading and what the rest of the post can deliver. Comparing volume alone is not enough.

You can keep the cause or the process in suspense. Do not make readers guess what the post is even about. The same principle works for article headlines.

4. Make the body deliver on the opening

Different kinds of material call for different structures:

  • An opinion: state the judgment, give reasons or examples, and explain where the judgment applies.
  • A tutorial: describe the obstacle, give the steps, and tell readers how to check the result.
  • A resource or tool: explain whom it suits, how to use it, and its limitations. Labels such as “must-have” and “bookmark this” are not enough.
  • An experience: explain what happened, which turning point changed your view, and what you took from it.

A short post can compress these into a few sentences. In a longer post or thread, each paragraph or entry should answer a specific question. Extra space is no reason to keep delaying the important information.

5. End with a small action the reader can complete

If you want readers to do something, replace “try it now” with a clear next step.

For this article, that might be:

Open a recent X post you wrote and remove emotional words such as “holy shit,” “mind-blowing,” or “insane.” If all that remains is a verdict, add a specific fact, example, or use case, then rewrite the first sentence.

Not every post needs a call to action. An opinion can end on its judgment; a personal account can end on how the experience felt. If you want a discussion, ask a relevant question that someone can actually answer rather than mechanically demanding reposts and bookmarks.

Here is how I might compress this article into a short post:

All 6 of these popular X posts open with “holy shit.” Remove those words and there is still conflict, a story, or a promise of value. Try removing “holy shit,” “mind-blowing,” and “insane” from your own draft. If all that remains is “this tool is incredible,” add one sentence: who does it help, and what problem does it solve? Explain the value first. Decide whether to shout afterwards.

Before publishing, check three things: did the body deliver what the opening promised, have you separated fact from judgment, and what can the reader take away?

Next time, the first question need not be whether the opening is exciting enough. Ask what you still give the reader after removing the exclamation.


Sources and limits